Wednesday, July 6, 2011

The Enemy of Great

Do you know that expression, "Good is the enemy of Great?" It sounds good doesn't it? I mean, everyone knows we're a country of slackers who want to get the most while doing the least. Everyone knows that if we just worked a bit harder and stretched ourselves a bit further we could... Oh, I don't know; you finish that sentence.

It's taken me a long time to figure out why I was so fed up with and annoyed by that expression. Now I've come to realize that it's actually the word "Great" that is driving me crazy. We've veered off the path towards a Greatness that really matters and are settling for a Faux Great that is breathtaking, but empty- like a movie set. To achieve a kind "Great" that is rich, full, complex and complete, I think the expression should be "Efficiency is the enemy of Great." Or at least it should be in my two lines of work.

Have you ever tried to rush a two year old or a preschooler out the door in the morning? They don't rush. The more you try to rush them, the less they move. It's shocking how many tiny distractions they can find for every, "Come on! We have to go!" that you through out. As your blood pressure went up and up and their little heels dug further in, did you find yourself being less than "Great" as you screamed, they cried and you all got in the van out of breath?

Have you ever tried to get a middle schooler efficiently through an afternoon of sports, homework and church activities? Did you feel less than "Great" when you realized that in six hours of nagging and coaxing you finally had the kid off to bed and all the work completed, but without ever hearing what was on his heart? Did the glow of accomplishment grow dim as you double checked that the homework was in the backpack only to find a note from a friend/enemy/teacher sharing news of real importance that your child hand never had a chance to share with you?

In my other job, fifth grade teacher, it's even worse. I can go whole days, even weeks, charging through lessons in place value, spelling rules, and causes of the seasons without ever once taking time to listen to the story of the birthday party over the weekend or worse yet, the loss of the pet/grandparent/brother. What kind of loss am I creating with my "Just a minute," and "Not right now?"

To the outside world any of my kids' test scores, report cards and achievements, at home or school, could make it look like I was "Great," but I don't think that's the measuring stick I want to be measured by. I know how naive and sappy that sounds. I also know that it sounds like a cop out, a lazy, slacker path. But sometimes what's true doesn't sound like common sense.

I need to be less efficient in both jobs. Kids need space and time to move, to breathe, to unfold, and they need to do it by their own internal clocks. Kids tell you what's on their hearts when they have the need, not when you have the time. They need you to be present, which means no multi-tasking while you listen, hold, love them.

Raising humans is the opposite of efficient. It's messy. It's circular. It's erratic. It's chaotic. Raising "Great" humans flies in the face of many of business's best practices. That feels scary. Good business practices can be easily measured; you can quickly tell if you're doing the job right. It requires little or no faith; just input the right formulas and the perfect widget will pop out the other side.

Humans, kids, aren't business goals, aren't machines, aren't put on earth for the purpose of producing anything. I personally believe they were put here for the delight and joy of their Creator, but even if you don't believe that, you have to see people as being something greater than product that they can offer to a world with far too many products already.

I say, go ahead, give in to that urge to take the long way, to say "No" to one more thing, to cut the to-do list in half. If you get really good at it, then you could write a best seller called, "Efficiency is the enemy of Great!" but you probably won't have time.

Sunday, June 12, 2011

Gifts

It's been quite a spring for me, as teacher. The world of education has been truly up in arms. There has been protesting and letter writing and facebooking and phone call campaigns, all trying to make education a financial priority and teaching a profession to respect within the circles of power across the country.

In the middle of all of this I was asked to take on two projects for my daughters' school. The first project was to put together a memory book for a 4th-6th grade teacher who was retiring after 43 years of teaching. My job was to take stories that former students posted to facebook and combine them with pictures into a digital scrapbook. Within minutes of agreeing to take on that project I was asked to do the program for the 1st-3rd grade play. That project involved interviewing each and every one of 74 cast members.

For a moment, and then again at various times, I was overwhelmed by what I had agreed to do. I took these projects on at the time of year when the responsibilities for my own classroom are immense. What was I thinking?!

I have never been so grateful that I agreed to do something crazy. Both of those projects turned out to be much greater gifts to me than I was to them. As I interviewed each little kid about why they liked being in the play, what they liked to do for fun and who they would like to thank for helping them out in life, I was reminded of the person that each student is. Each person in my classroom, in every classroom, is a little, and sometimes not so little, person in his or her own right. Each one of them is someone's daughter, son, grandchild, friend. None of them is a reading score or a math score. They are lovers of games and books, of music and tricks. They loved being in the play because they got to express themselves, to sing, to show emotion, to pretend to be someone else. Most of them gave thanks to their family members, but a few gave thanks to their teachers. One little girl said, "I'd like to thank Mrs. Hall for having me in her class. She's a good teacher because she sounds like a teacher and she works good like a teacher should."

I wonder what she'll be saying about her teachers 43 years from now. I might have gotten a peek at that future. I was born the year Mr. Huyser started teaching, so as I prepared the memory book, I read stories from many people who are my age. They were thinking back over almost a whole life time, and what do they remember? They do remember a few things that they were taught. They remember that they had to learn to do their times table in two minutes or less, and be able to name all 50 states. A few mentioned books that Mr. H. read to them. But that's about it. What I read was page after page of memories of places they went and adventures they had bike riding, camping, dog sled races. I also read about lessons learned in how to treat people and how to treat yourself. I read about how he touched them by believing in them when it seemed like no one else did. After 43 years or 15 years or 3 years, what they remembered was how he touched their hearts.

As I worked on these projects I frequently found myself in tears. Sometimes they were tears of laughter, "I'd like to thank Michael Jackson," one first grader said. Other times they were tears of sadness. Sadness because I saw Mr. Huyser's retirement as something bigger, the passing of an era. It seems the time for building, growing people of character, bright, unique humans has past into history. It feels to me that my job now is to create workers, cogs, efficient producers of goods and services.

Sometimes though, I cried because I was inspired and touched. I was so inspired by the stories of the past generation and the thoughts of the current generation, that I welled up frequently as I worked. At 16 years into teaching I needed to be reminded of what's important. I may have been given a very different job to do than teachers of 40 years ago, but nothing and no one can stop me from being a good teacher. No one can stop me from treating children in a way that they will still remember 43 years from now how they felt in my class and how they were taught to treat others. No one can stop me from believing in each and every kid regardless of how she looks on paper. I don't need anyone in the circles of power to value what I do in order for it to make a difference in the circles that really matter.

Friday, March 4, 2011

True Story

I loaded up my van tonight at about 6:45 with five seventh grade boys. We headed out to pick up one eighth grader who had forgotten to tell his mom that he needed a ride. He was punished by the other boys by being forced to sit center back, also known as the squeezy seat. We were headed to a teen center type place that had opened recently to celebrate JD's 13th birthday.

The van was filled with the sounds of all the boys trying to gossip over each other. I heard about the boy from their school who is in trouble with the law, a girl whose birthday was celebrated by the entire cafeteria, how one of the boys had wormed his way into the Senior's year book pictures, and a shouting match about who was better- seventh or eighth graders. "Seniors," won.

Even though it's early March, it was raining quite hard and was fairly warm out and with all that talking and breathing going on, my windows were quickly fogged up. I cranked up the defrost in an effort to see where I was going. Where WAS I going? "By the way Mom, you know the 3Mile Project isn't actually on 3 Mile?"

"No, I didn't actually know that. Well we'll find it I guess. Your dad found it a few weeks ago." I slowed down to take the exit my husband had told me to take and peered out the still fogged windows. "Boys, you're just going to have to stop breathing; I can't see." No reply, not even a chuckle. I felt the skin on my face blister and start to peel from the heat of the defroster, so I rolled down the windows.

I turned onto 3 Mile Rd and saw a long line of cars waiting to turn left at the first street. "Is that it JD? It must be with all the cars."

"No, it was further on. Plus, there's semis in that line, why would they be there?"

"Because the place is a rehabbed warehouse and there are probably other warehouses on the street," I think, but don't say. What I do say is, "Are you sure?"

"Yes, I'm sure." There was general agreement from the other boy who had gone before.

We drove on a bit until we came to a light. "It's either down here or this is the street it wasn't on and we had to turn around."

"How far do I go before I quit," I ask.

"Far. Oh wait, not far. Where's the Cheese Kurlz factory? Oh there's the bridge we saw before when we realized this was the wrong road and turned around."

I turn around.

"It must be this next one," my darling son said. I was soon going to hate those words. We drove down every street along that mile stretch of road, finally coming out on another road several miles back towards my house. I had started calling my husband back at the first wrong turn, but I got no answer. Later he told me that I only called three times, but I would have sworn I call every three minutes. Finally I called my sister. With the power of Google, she could help me from Minnesota.

The boys had looked on their registration forms and found the name of the road, but we just couldn't seem to find it. I was driving hunched forward over the steering wheel trying to see, eyes dried and face flaming from the heat, and ears pierced from the noise. "Look at the road signs boys, Aunt Christi says it's past Bristol." Bristol, by the way was that first wrong road we had gone down, the road we wanted was before that one, or now that we'd gone so far, past it.

"There it is! I told you it would be the next street!" Well, with a prediction like that, a kid has to be right eventually. "Turn left."

I turn left and go maybe two tenths of a mile. "Look around geniuses! What do you see!? I believe we should have turned right back there, not left." I head back to 3 Mile to cross to the other side.

We pulled up to the intersection and I looked across the street. What do you know, we were right back where I had seen all the cars and thought we should probably turn way back 15 minutes before. What are the odds that my son will change his know-it-all ways?

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Whatcha Shoulda Done Is...

My family and I are going to Orlando in a few weeks. We plan to go to Universal Studios to see Harry Potter World, to Downtown Disney to see Cirque du Soleil and to Boma at Animal Kingdom Lodge for dinner. Right now, many of you are thinking, "Oh, what you really need to do while you're there is..." And I'm more or less fine with that. My friends Charlotte and Sue, for example, have given me many great suggestions over the years that have made my vacations awesome.

What's really going to drive me crazy is what's going to happen after I purchase the Cirque tickets or choose my day to go to HP World, or even when I tell about my trip after I get back. That's when someone, or in reality, several someones, are going to say, "Oh, that's great! What you should have done though is.... then you would have really gotten a great deal, had a great time, whatever."

What IS UP with that?! What good does your information do me now except to make my experience seem less great that I had been thinking it was right before you said that?! It's not like I can take your advice for "next time." There is no next time! These are the kinds of trips and activities you do once. (Except, this is going to be my third dinner and Boma. I never thought I'd be the kind of person who has a favorite Orlando restaurant, but that's a different post.)

The same thing happens after you make a big purchase decision. Inevitably someone will say, "Oh, did you know you could have gotten that Apple computer for less if you had worked angle blah blah blah?" Or, you comment that you really enjoyed the show you saw in Chicago and someone says, "I've heard that's a great show, but you really should have made time for..."

"You paid how much for those plane tickets? You could get a great deal if you went to 'Imsuchabetterdealfinderthanyou.com."

"Skiing at Boyne last weekend? Did you know you could have used Shell Gas coupons and skied for free?"

"Huh. You paid XYZ for your replacement windows? My neighbor got his from Window Huckster for only PDQ."

Actually, it's not limited to big purchases. Have you ever bought new shoes only to be told how there was a great sale on them at some store other than where you bought them? Does the person really think that this is helpful? Does she really expect that you're going to take back the pair of shoes that you got for $40 and then go buy them somewhere else for $30? My time is worth more than $10 an hour! (Although, not according to the Gov. of WI and Fox News pundits, but again, I'm dipping into other posts.) I was enjoying my shoes plenty, no matter how much I spent on them, thank you very much. Now that you've opened your big mouth I can no longer enjoy my shoes; instead, I have to devote my energies to deciding whether or not I should take them back and go get a better deal, or should I just sulk over my inability to get a good deal in the first place?!

I'm starting to feel that this isn't really about you helping me at all. It's about me helping you feel like a smarter/better/cooler person, whether I want to help you with that or not. That's really what this is, isn't it? Not that most people would admit it, but we all feel like losers to some extent. We second guess ourselves and doubt our own worth. The quickest and easiest way to feel less like a loser is to at least be less of a loser than someone else. It's such a hard drug to avoid isn't it?

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Gifts

It's still a month to my birthday, but my husband is a bit of an impulse shopper, so I already have my present. I got a new composter.

No, this is not going to be a post about lame-brained husbands and their idiotic gifts. I was actually thrilled. I already have a composter, but there are many things that I don't like about it. It's ugly; it's too tall for the kids to really get the scraps into, it's rusty and falling apart; it's taller than my fence and my neighbor has to look at it. I've had it for a long time and I've wanted a new one almost since I got this one. I couldn't ever get a new one though because there was nothing really wrong with the one I had. I'm against replacing perfectly usable items, especially when there's nothing to be done with it except use it to increase the size of an already too large landfill.

Russ' gift wasn't really the composter, it was freedom from guilt. I don't have to feel bad about getting rid of the ugly composter and putting in the low profile new composter. I don't have to feel bad about spending money to get something that I don't really need. I don't even have to feel guilty about the fate of the old composter; Russ already told me that the old composter had to go and that I'm not allowed to try and turn it into planter or some other form of repurposing.

The reason that this perfectly practical gift is a joy and not a curse is because it has what all good gifts have, deep knowledge by the giver of the receiver. My husband knows me. He knows that I would not go out and buy a composter when the one we have is fine, even with a hole. He knows this because I won't go out and buy new laundry baskets even though the ones I have have broken handles. I can't get rid of them because where would they go?! My husband knows that what I really need for my birthday is a break from guilt and always trying to do the right thing. Knowing that he knows what's important to me and knowing that he knows what makes me tick, makes me feel as loved as any fancy, frilly, romantic gift.

The only tiny sadness to the gift was that I had planned to ask for a new storm door for the front door. Oh well, Mother's Day is not too long after my birthday.

Saturday, January 22, 2011

The Good Dishes

I'm not saying that other people's way is wrong here, it's just not for me. I loath plastic dishes. Plastic storage containers, love 'em, but not dishes. And that includes the utensils and glasses. It's not a health issue or an environmental issue or any other high minded ideal. I just don't like the look and feel of them. I'd rather drink out of a re-purposed glass jar than a plastic cup. I'll pick the itty bitty glass wine glass over the mongo plastic wine "glass."

This plan to use glass and ceramic ware was simply a matter of taste for quite a few years. There were no consequences one way or the other. Then I had children. At my baby shower I received plastic dishes and plastic sippy cups and plastic utensils. I used them for awhile. You know how it is when you're first starting out in parenting, all the little baby gadgets are kind of fun, and those no-spill sippy cups are genius. When kid number two came along however, I was over a lot of things. Plastic dishes were one of them. (Although the genius sippy cups got a pass.) I started setting the table with the same dishes for everyone.

I didn't have the sort of dishes a person would be attached to or proud of. I believe my mom collected them a few at a time in a grocery store deal when I was still in middle school. It's a good thing too, because it wasn't long before those babies were old enough to start helping out with the dinner clean up and I watched my supply of dishes quickly become depleted. Not that the kids were the first ones to break dishes; my husband and I are pretty clutzy ourselves. Eventually I didn't even have enough plates or glasses to set the table for a couple of guests.

For my 34th birthday, after 10 years of marriage, I asked for and received a new set of plates and bowls. This was a good time to rethink my aversion to plastic. My children were five, three, and unborn at the time. I could keep the new, very awesome, dishes only for adults, or only for guests. I really liked these new dishes. I liked that I had gotten to pick them out myself. I liked that they were bold colors and had a handmade look. I liked that they came in six different colors and made the table look cheery in any season.

That love was the downfall of the dishes. And when I say downfall, think, slipping from small fingers, crashing into sinks, falling to the floor, being knocked off of tables. I could have gone back to plastic and kept the dishes safe so that I could enjoy them far into the future. I didn't. And I'm not sorry.

I went the route of enjoying the dishes now. I set my table with those cheery dishes each night and smiled at the sight of them. When they got broke, I did feel sad, but I moved on pretty fast. Eventually I took advantage of their mix match appearance and started filling in the set with odds and ends I picked up at Goodwill, or on clearance here and there. I decided spending big money on dishes was a stress I didn't want in my life. I wanted a colorful table set with real dishes. I wanted dishes that said dinner was important and the time together was to be valued.

I get a finite number of dinners with my family, and nobody is telling what that number is, so I want dinner time to matter. If I saved the good dishes back so that I would be able to enjoy them long into the future, who would I enjoy them with?

Friday, January 7, 2011

Snow

New Year' Eve dawned. Right, there's no way to actually finish that sentence because New Year's Eve never really did dawn; there was just a lessening of the dark by a bit. It was gray, wet, ugly and warm. Yes, warm, in Michigan on December 31st. It was so warm that I had to go out and buy ice for my cooler to keep all my New Year's Eve drinks cold. The mud, puddles and smell of damp put me in a foul mood. It was so ugly out that I felt like yelling at someone.

I won't say that all that warm rain ruined New Year's Eve; I am a woman who knows how to rise above her circumstances. I will say though, that on the evening of New Year's Day as we walked out into a gorgeous snow globe world in my friends' front yard, my girls and I were moved to break into song on the front porch. I hadn't even know that snow was predicted and it was a lovely surprise.

Now I'm sitting on the front edge of "the storm of the century," and I say, "Bring it!" I'm so excited that we might get a foot of snow. The only thing I like more than a foot of snow... is two feet of snow! I love how quiet it is when it's snowing. Cars go by and you don't even hear them. It's a kind of quiet that you don't get in modern times. When I'm out in the snow I don't hear that hum that is a constant part of modern life.

Snow is magical; it turns ugly lumps of old lawn furniture in my back yard into smooth, elegant statues. It covers my many landscaping sins in a blanket of diamonds. Snow and ice make the sad looking bare branches of the maples and oaks sparkle and shine with joy. Mountains appear where there once was flat, barren parking lot.

I used to hear people say, "At least you don't have to shovel it," whenever it rained in the winter, but if it weren't for the fact that we have to get out and shovel, I'd never see my neighbors all winter long. We may not stand out and chat as long as we do in the summer, but at least we check in a bit. I love how all the old guys with big snowblowers come out and try and outdo each other clearing sidewalks and old lady's mailboxes. I also love that shoveling snow is a good reason to let myself off the hook from having to work out!

So, I'm going to build a fire, pour a glass of wine, let my son stay up late and enjoy the forced slowdown to life that a good winger storm brings. Unless, of course, the power goes out, but I won't be able to post a blog about that so you'll never hear me whining.