Friday, July 18, 2008

I'm Just Sayin'

I listen to the Satellite Sisters' podcast.  I enjoy it; it's funny and even informative sometimes. The last two episodes have had the subject of vegans and trying not to eat meat, and both times someone went on and on about all the meat substitutes that are now available.  Apparently it goes way beyond toferky now.

Which brings me to an odd and long standing pet peeve of mine.  If you're going to not eat meat, go for it, but why substitute with "food?"  If you look at the ingredient list on the meatless chicken nuggets, it's a good paragraph in length and many of the ingredients are unpronounceable. I don't see how that's any healthier or environmentally friendly than meat.  The only thing it has going for it is that it's not obviously cruel.

I think if you're going to give up meat, and I've been taking some small steps in that direction, it makes more sense to me to substitute in real foods.  I like to replace meat with beans, cheese, eggs (I know these are still animal products, but I just can't go all the way.) and tofu, but not tofu that has been turned into fake meat.


Sunday, July 6, 2008

Chore Time

I'm sure I'd get few arguments, except from kids, that chores are good for kids.  It builds character, makes them more responsible, less selfish, blah blah blah.  I think kids should do chores because it's good for their imaginations.  Chores are boring and mindless at any age. Kids, who are extremely allergic to boring and mindless, have to find some way to cope. 

In exchange for being let off cleaning the playroom, JD has agreed to scoop dog poop in the yard every three days.  Believe it or not, he never complains. He doesn't rush out to do it, and it can take him awhile, but it gets done.  The other day I looked out the window to see if he was still working and I saw him leaning on the shovel talking away to someone, someone only he could see. True, if he were a little older that would be cause for concern, but I'm pretty sure that ten year olds should still be making up imaginary scenarios. I had to giggle because I remember quite clearly talking to myself in the mirror while I cleaned the bathroom when I was a kid.  I used to make up commercials for my cleaning products.  Who knows what JD was talking about.  Perhaps he was making up another song.  Earlier in the summer he made up a little work song for himself.  He used the tune from a little kids Sunday School song called, "Who needs help?"  JD's version goes,

"Where is the poop?
I look and see
There is the poop
Right next to me!"

Repeat until all poop is scooped.

JD is not the only creative soul at our house.  Later the same day that I had seen JD talking to himself, Abby stopped me as I was walking past the bathroom.  She was supposed to be in there cleaning the sink. 

"Mom, Mom! Wait! Come in here!  You have to see my special scrubbing that I do! Watch!"

She then proceeded to do a scrub job that pretty much used every part of her body.  You might have even called it a dance.  There were large arm circles that sped around the sink in a sloshing motion and then hip circles and shoulder shrugs as well.  There was also a little song that went with it, but I didn't quite catch the lyrics as they weren't all words that were known to me.  It was something to do with scrubbing and dubbing and do dah do do dah scrub, something, something, something.  She was very proud, and the sink, as well as the floor, were quite clean.

I haven't caught Rachel with anything too creative yet, unless I count the endless organizing of her possessions into "art studios," or "offices," or "club houses," etc., as creative.  I suppose it might be. 

At any rate, I see this whole chore thing as a win win.  We'll see what the kids say in twenty years.

Wednesday, July 2, 2008

A Story and a Few Questions

You may or may not know that I have really wrestled with prayer over the last few years.  Sadly it's not that I've wrestled in prayer, although sometimes that has been the case.  I've longed to find the meaning of it, the purpose of it, the peace of it.  Because I've been unclear in my own mind about prayer, it's been more than a little challenging to teach prayer to my children and answer their questions.  

I don't know, perhaps my children are ordinary, but to me their questions and musings are quite extraordinary.  They ask me why bad things happen, is God punishing them, does God really love the people in the stories to whom bad things happen? You know, stuff like that.  JD is especially thoughtful about all matters, outside of keeping track of things and everyday tasks. I don't invent answers, and I never claim to know it all. They would find me out much too quickly.  I usually reply with whatever honest answer I'm at in my own journey.

JD has had two bikes stolen from the library near our house in the last month.  It was particularly devastating the second time because it seemed so cruel.  Both JD and I shed tears over the matter, although he doesn't know that.  At dinner on the day of the second incident it was JD's turn to pray.  Of course he prayed for God to find his bike for him.  My willingness to try praying for anything that matters has improved lately and I joined him in his prayer, in my own heart.

This morning JD seemed pretty cheerful and didn't even mention the bike situation himself.  I suggested that we both think of ways to replace the bike,  jobs he could do to earn money, that kind of thing.  We didn't really dwell on it though, too depressing for me.

Around 11:00 the mom of one of Rachel's friends phone to invite her to play.  I know the mom pretty well and we spent a few minutes catching up with each other as we were making plans for the girls.  As is my usual custom, I walked around my house putting things away as I was talking on the phone.  As I came up the stairs from the basement something of JD's caught my eye, probably his shoes laying in the middle of the floor.  The sight triggered a thought.

"On a completely different note," I said to Suzanne, "You don't happen to have a boy's bike that you're getting ready to sell, do you?"  Suzanne has a son that is a year older and a good deal taller than JD.

"Actually," she said, "I just gave away a bike to a friend, but the last time I saw her son ride over here, he wasn't riding that bike.  You know what I can do? As soon as I get off  the phone with you, I'll call her up and see if her son is using the bike."

About a half hour later Suzanne called back. "Cara is on her way with Jennifer to pick up Rachel.  They should be there shortly.  And I talked to my friend.  She's not using the bike. She'll drop it off in a little bit and you can pick it up when you pick up Rachel."

I was stunned.  I actually stood still. "Seriously?!  I can't believe it.  Thank you so much!  Will you let me pay you for the bike?"

"Tonia, I gave the bike to Patrice, of course I'm just going to give it to you!  I hope JD will like the bike.  It's pretty heavy duty. Actually it's a stunt bike, but it looks cool for sure."

Later, as we were out and buying a bike like, JD said something about how amazingly it had all worked out.  I decided to take, in my view, a risk.

"Well, I guess this is how God answered your prayer to get your bike back.  He does tend do things  in unexpected ways."

"You're right mom!  And I thought God was just punishing me for something bad I did.  Maybe my bike was stolen because I'm meant to have the stunt bike so I can grow up to be a BMX rider!"

I went with the extremely safe, "We'll see."

Since that conversation, I've been rehashing like crazy.  What do I want JD to take away from this experience?  I've come down to three important questions and there are no easy answers to any of them.

Did God really answer his prayer?

Does it matter?

What will happen when God doesn't or seems not to answer his prayer?

I'm relieved to say that for now, it's just me asking those questions, but the day is coming when he's going to be right there wrestling with me.  I hope when that day comes I have the strength to let him do his own wrestling and not try to hold him back with easy religious cliches.

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

Miss Reid, It Wasn't Enough

When I was tenish I was playing in my Grandma's backyard with my cousins.  I have quite a few cousins who are right around my age so we made quite a gang.  A gang like that needs organizing, so, as I often did, I organized everyone.  Unfortunately, I organized whatever it was we were playing to my benefit.  It seems like we were doing wagon rides or something and I was getting more rides than the other kids. We were taking turns pushing each other I guess.

I can't recall now who was pushing the wagon, but as it careened across the patio and past the sliding glass door, my Uncle Hack stuck his head out and hollered, "Hey, how come it seems like Tonia is always the one riding in the wagon?  That doesn't seem fair!"

Immediately I hopped out of the wagon and reorganized the game so that I had fewer rides than the other kids.  I was mortified that someone would think that I was mean or took advantage of other people.  It changed my whole life in fact.  A few years later when I was organizing my neighborhood friends to do a backyard play, I took great care to give the starring role to another girl.  I retained the part of director, but I figured that giving up the glam job of  leading lady was keeping things fair. 

It seems reasonable that his was not the only comment ever made to me about my leadership style.  I must have been called bossy by a lot of people.  I guess you could say that Uncle Hack wasn't even saying I was bossy, just unfair, but I lumped it in with all the other, "Tonia, you're too bossy," comments.  In fact his comment cut right through to my heart and have stayed with me for about 30 years becoming the representative memory of all the times I was told that I was too bossy.

I kept right on taking charge of things though. I don't think I could stop myself.  It must have been pretty noticeable too because when I was in the ninth grade, my history teacher, the adored Miss Reid, told me I should run for student council because I was a "good leader."  

I told her that it would never happen because, "Student council is about being popular, not about being a good leader."

I didn't even try student leadership for another five years when I went off to CMU.  Then I was elected to be the floor rep for my hall council when I was a freshman. Later I took on many other leadership roles including being not only a resident advisor, but one who trained other RAs. 

So it seems like I got over the comments about being too bossy and even took the good in the comment from my uncle and tried to be fair while I was being bossy.  I practiced what my mother called, "The art of letting other people have your own way." They were happy, I was happy, things were good.

And then some jerk, whose opinion means NOTHING to me, told me that in our group of friends everyone always did whatever I suggested and no one else was allowed to have ideas or steer the group in any direction that wasn't mine. This person is a whiney, immature, ego maniac, and somehow he was still able to instantly kick my butt back to being ten years old.  I wouldn't plan or organize anything straightforwardly again.  I ceased to be a real and decisive leader.  Immediately.

This time there was no Miss Reid to give me the power to lead and somehow I haven't become adult enough to take the power for myself. I never, or rarely, feel like it's my place to say something. I usually go find someone else, tell them my idea and then convince them to bring it to the group. I do it both with friends and coworkers.

I've been thrashing around for a conclusion to this post for about thirty minutes now. You might be able to tell by the length.  I don't know what the final observation should be.  I don't know if people without clearly defined authority given to them by a position or title should just take charge.  I don't know if adults even want to be organized by their peers in the same way that kids do.  

I don't know.  I don't know a lot.  I do like to think though that I'm not bossy because mean goes with bossy.  I just have a lot of ideas and I get excited about them and I want to try them out. What do I do with all of those ideas if I don't share them?

Monday, June 30, 2008

So I saw my old friend Janel last week, although I should immediately clarify that she is not old. She, as she reminded me repeatedly, is a good six months younger than me. Outside of my cousins, whom I definitely consider friends, Janel is my oldest friend.  I think we met in either eighth or ninth grades.  We stayed friends through the ups and downs of teen girl life and she remains my only actual contact from high school. Well, until last week when we also hooked up with our friend Roberta with whom we've been friends since the eighth grade as well. Anyway, all that to say, "She knew me when."

Just a few days before I had lunch with Janel and Roberta, I had a soul baring session with my girlfriends here in GR. We were sharing things that we struggle with. These girls already know me pretty well; I've been friends with them for ten or more years.  When I commented, "I'm so needy!  I hate that I'm so needy!" there were confused looks all around the room. 

Heidi said, "What does that mean?  I don't get what you're saying." Apparently I don't seem as needy on the outside. 

Later, driving home, Heidi and I were rehashing the evening when I referred to myself as being, "so dramatic." 

"What?  That's the second thing tonight you've said that surprised me."

Seems that my efforts to rein in the drama have been reasonably successful. 

Back to lunch with my "old" friends. (Janel, that is perfectly acceptable use of quotation marks, and even in my mind I did not do them in the air!)  I repeated the story about not being seen as needy or dramatic. 

It's a credit to their self control that they didn't snort their drinks or choke on their food.  They merely chuckled, shook their heads and gave me the, "Yeah right," look. Of course, when Janel, Roberta and I were in more frequent contact, those two character traits were on daily display.

I'm not saying that I have or haven't grown and changed.  I think you could make the case either way.  I do have more self control, which all good grown ups should have, and I do have more confidence generally.  On the other hand, in my head I still react with fierce drama to sometimes small things and I have a fierce need to be reassured.  Wouldn't it be healthier to at least acknowledge that a little bit more?  Is self control just a cover up for honesty? 

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

Here's a book list from one of my students this year.  She and I have similar taste in books; in fact I've read about half of her list. She's a very enthusiastic reader and we used to discuss books when I was on the playground for recess duty. The books are generally fourth grade reading level through middle school, with one picture book thrown in.  There's a nice mix of genre as well.  If you read any of them, post your thoughts here or on
Good Reads.

In no particular order, except this is the order she gave it to me:

Stargirl (sequel is Love, Stargirl) realistic fiction, Jerry Spinelli

The Sisters Grimm, fantasy series, Michael Buckley

Rules, realistic fiction, Cynthia Lord

Chasing Redbird, Sharon Creech (the genre is a little unclear and I haven't read it.)

Granny Torelli Makes Soup, realistic fiction, Sharon Creech

Ella Enchanted, fantasy, Gail Carson Levine

Fairest, fantasy, Gail Carson Levine

The Two Princesses of Bamarre, fantasy, Gail Carson Levine

Eggs (A.'s note: the beginning is a little bit boring but it gets better.)realistic fiction, Jerry Spinelli

Shug, realistic fiction, Jenny Han

The Last Dog on Earth, I'd call it science fiction, Daniel Ehrenhaft

Kira Kira, realistic fiction, Cynthia Kodohata

The Last Book on the Universe, science fiction, Rodman Philbrick

Otherwise Known as Sheila the Great, realistic fiction, Judy Blume

The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane, fantasy/realistic mix, Kate DiCamillo

The Tiger Rising, realistic fiction, Kate DiCamillo

A  Corner of the Universe, realistic fiction, Ann M. Martin

A Cricket in Times Square, reality/fantasy mix, George Selden

The Wanderer, realistic fiction, Sharon Creech

Firegirl, realistic fiction, Tony Abbott

A Crooked Kind of Perfect, realistic fiction, Linda Urban

The Invention of Hugo Cabret, fantasy/reality mix, Brian Selznick

Zathura, fantasy, Chris VanAlsburg (note from A. See the movie!  It shows Bella! (from Twilight)She's not really the star.)

The Penderwicks, realistic fiction, Jeanne Birdsall

The Naked Mole-Rat Letters, realistic fiction, Mary Amato

Ophie out of Oz, realistic fiction, Kathleen O'Dell





Monday, June 2, 2008

Boys and Frogs and Snakes and Other Dangers

I picked up my sweaty, filthy son from daycare after school today.  He was radiant.  It was the best day ever, he said.  His class had gone on a bike trip of about eight miles.  Along the way he had jumped in river and swam across a pond. 

"Were you supposed to be in the pond?" I asked.

"Yes." His voice clearly said, "Duh, mom."

"How do you know?"

"Ms. Lee was standing right there watching us from the other side of the pond."

I was thinking, "So? She was probably wondering what the heck those boys were doing in the pond and what was she going to do about it now?"  Aloud, I said, "What did she say when you got over to her?"

"Good job!"

Man, I love that woman.  I would have been all afraid that they would get in trouble with their parents, or that I would get in trouble with my boss.  I would never have let the kids in the pond, and if they had gone in, I would have scolded them.  I think Ms. Lee is a far wiser teacher than I am.

JD had also caught frogs and snakes and even a snake with a fish in it's mouth.  He had seen dangerous snakes and even leeches. I bet I heard him say five times that he had been bitten by a snake, but it was just a little bite.  There was a turtle claw and some seaweed in his pocket, and the telling of his tale filled nearly every minute until bedtime.

As I listened and watched him I was once again reminded that boys need space to do dangerous things. (Perhaps some girls do as well, but I think they are different kinds of dangerous things.) I don't know why they need to risk life and limb, but they do.  I think that's why more boys than girls play battle themed video games.  We don't live in a world where there is much room for a boy to run on his own and risk much of anything, but they still have that same urge to test themselves and to explore their physical limits. All that many boys have is video games.  I don't imagine that it's quite as satisfying as JD's day of rivers and ponds was.