In some ways this is my third part to my high school rant. Of the comments that I got on my two previous posts, Lara's was the most sympathetic to the study and the numbers that they showed. "Interesting," I thought. Then I thought about it some more. I can see why she would be harder on the schools than other people. In her job she has to try and convince teachers to try new things. Sometimes that goes really well and the teacher is enthusiastic and takes the suggestions and runs with them. Sometimes it doesn't go so well. They want to do what they've always done and are completely convinced that the entire fault of the not learning lies with the kid. Having seen the results of listening or not listening to the practices that Lara tries to teach teachers to use, I'd say she's got some ground to stand on in blaming the schools for negligence.
On the other side, I've sat an MANY parent teacher conferences and said, "Listen, you need to make sure your kid does her reading homework every night. She is way behind and even though I'm doin' all I can for her at school, she needs to practice on her own." After I make this speech one of three things happens. Sometimes the parent totally gets it and cracks the whip and homework magic happens. More likely I get one of these two responses. "Yep, yep. We'll get right on it," and absolutely nothing changes, or "We don't have time for homework because we have sports, church, family things, whatever." That’s the kind of thing that makes me want to tear my hair out!
I know; there are two sides to every story. All I'm sayin' is let's share the blame. I don’t expect one person or group to just up and shoulder the burden alone. No one group of people caused the problem. Parents send kids to school with a lot of baggage and expect the school to do all the work. Schools get overwhelmed, some would say lazy, and don't even bother to do what they can do.
I guess we're not even on the same side, the side of the kid. It's like I said at the end of my last rant, we could get messed up in blaming and never move on to solving. But other than what I do with my fifth graders and my own kids at home, I really don't know how to help. I really want to, but what can I do?
Which leads me to rant 4, super teacher movies, but that's for another day.
All that stuff that I think about when I'm driving around or doing other mundane tasks. Including stuff I love, stuff I hate, weird theories that I have, and arguments about why I'm right about stuff.
Saturday, November 3, 2007
Friday, November 2, 2007
Rant Part 2
I've decided I'm not done ranting about the "dropout factory" schools. I have two more beefs- for now.
I once read that there is a correlation (I know, that doesn't mean causation) between the size of a kid's vocabulary when he/she enters Kindergarten and his or her success in high school. Did you notice that I said "ENTERS" kindergarten? Who was in charge of building that vocabulary, hmm?
I'm also mad about the reporting on this study. On our local news' website the area Superintendent was given the chance to air his dissenting view. He says that the State of MI numbers show much higher rates of graduation. The story went on to focus on the fact that the state does not count students who are in jail as being dropouts because there are education programs for them while they are incarcerated. This was the only portion of the discrepancy between the State of Michigan numbers and the Johns Hopkins numbers. It made it seem as though some 75% (the percentage that Johns Hopkins has dropping out) of this area's students are in jail! That's just irresponsible reporting. What the heck high school did those reporters graduate from anyway?
I realize there's a huge danger in, on both sides of this fight, placing blame anywhere. We can get so caught up in trying to win the debate about who's fault this is that we have no energy left to do something about the problem. So, if we all acknowlege that we have some work to do an then get busy and do it, we might get somewhere.
I once heard a brillant man say that we should pick up our cross daily and follow him. The shame of kids not graduating from high school is on all of us, on all of our crosses. Are we preachin' now?
I once read that there is a correlation (I know, that doesn't mean causation) between the size of a kid's vocabulary when he/she enters Kindergarten and his or her success in high school. Did you notice that I said "ENTERS" kindergarten? Who was in charge of building that vocabulary, hmm?
I'm also mad about the reporting on this study. On our local news' website the area Superintendent was given the chance to air his dissenting view. He says that the State of MI numbers show much higher rates of graduation. The story went on to focus on the fact that the state does not count students who are in jail as being dropouts because there are education programs for them while they are incarcerated. This was the only portion of the discrepancy between the State of Michigan numbers and the Johns Hopkins numbers. It made it seem as though some 75% (the percentage that Johns Hopkins has dropping out) of this area's students are in jail! That's just irresponsible reporting. What the heck high school did those reporters graduate from anyway?
I realize there's a huge danger in, on both sides of this fight, placing blame anywhere. We can get so caught up in trying to win the debate about who's fault this is that we have no energy left to do something about the problem. So, if we all acknowlege that we have some work to do an then get busy and do it, we might get somewhere.
I once heard a brillant man say that we should pick up our cross daily and follow him. The shame of kids not graduating from high school is on all of us, on all of our crosses. Are we preachin' now?
Thursday, November 1, 2007
Alright That's It. I Have Had It!
Maybe you've heard, but probably you haven't. Johns Hopkins University has released a report about high schools that that they are calling "dropout factories." Four of them are in my adopted West Michigan hometown. Argh! Was not all that I said when I saw the local coverage of the story.
I get that there are some things that the schools should be doing to get more kids to graduate. But how 'bout a little sharing of the blame here? I am willing to share the credit for my young student Johnny/Juan/Ju/Jovante if the student and the family and the community will share some of the blame. Come on people!
These kids who drop out of high school obviously had parents at one time; where the #@$* are they when the kid drops out? Did they do all they could do for Johnny/Juan/Ju/Jovante? Did they read to him when he was little, make sure he did his homework when he was in middle school, keep him involved and doing healthy activities? Did they feed him nutritious food around a table that had at least one adult present for multiple meals a week? Seriously people, if you don't do you part, why does the school have to perform miracles to "fix" your kid? We're only human too!
And don't get me started on all the white and Christian (black and white) people who move out of these schools instead of sticking around to fight for quality at the schools. Oh no, their babies are more precious than other people's babies. Gotta go. Whatever.
Alright, this post was more of a rant than a coherently argued case for working with schools instead of treating them like the enemy, but sometimes I just get tired. Maybe later I'll calm down and say something more logical and less emotional.
I get that there are some things that the schools should be doing to get more kids to graduate. But how 'bout a little sharing of the blame here? I am willing to share the credit for my young student Johnny/Juan/Ju/Jovante if the student and the family and the community will share some of the blame. Come on people!
These kids who drop out of high school obviously had parents at one time; where the #@$* are they when the kid drops out? Did they do all they could do for Johnny/Juan/Ju/Jovante? Did they read to him when he was little, make sure he did his homework when he was in middle school, keep him involved and doing healthy activities? Did they feed him nutritious food around a table that had at least one adult present for multiple meals a week? Seriously people, if you don't do you part, why does the school have to perform miracles to "fix" your kid? We're only human too!
And don't get me started on all the white and Christian (black and white) people who move out of these schools instead of sticking around to fight for quality at the schools. Oh no, their babies are more precious than other people's babies. Gotta go. Whatever.
Alright, this post was more of a rant than a coherently argued case for working with schools instead of treating them like the enemy, but sometimes I just get tired. Maybe later I'll calm down and say something more logical and less emotional.
Saturday, October 27, 2007
Happy Halloween!
This is my favorite holiday. It has been since I was a kid. I like Easter, and Christmas and the 4th of July too, oh, and Thanksgiving, but they all have one problem in common. Whenever I would get excited about gifts or stockings or fireworks or eggs, my dad would always say, "Don't forget the real reason that we celebrate. It's not all about the gifts you know."
Yes dad I do know. I know it so well because you are a very good dad and have raised me up right! Just because I'm excited about this superficial materialistic thing does NOT mean I am shallow!
But Halloween. It really is all about the candy and the costumes. That's it. That's all there is to it. Oh, I know other people have tried to make it about evil and crap like that, but I scoff at their efforts. None of them, no matter how evil they may be can out maneuver the American Marketing Juggernaut! Yes, candy sellers, costume makers and purveyors of decorations will triumph and Halloween will always be, "All about the goodies."
So here’s to the Draco Malfoy, Black Cat, and Little Red Riding Hood (who even got her dad to don a wolf mask) who reside at my house this year. Let the candy feasting begin!
Yes dad I do know. I know it so well because you are a very good dad and have raised me up right! Just because I'm excited about this superficial materialistic thing does NOT mean I am shallow!
But Halloween. It really is all about the candy and the costumes. That's it. That's all there is to it. Oh, I know other people have tried to make it about evil and crap like that, but I scoff at their efforts. None of them, no matter how evil they may be can out maneuver the American Marketing Juggernaut! Yes, candy sellers, costume makers and purveyors of decorations will triumph and Halloween will always be, "All about the goodies."
So here’s to the Draco Malfoy, Black Cat, and Little Red Riding Hood (who even got her dad to don a wolf mask) who reside at my house this year. Let the candy feasting begin!
Thursday, October 25, 2007
I Think I'd Like to British, Maybe
This summer Sue (who is so young and beautiful with all of her long blond hair) and Charlotte had a YouTube link on their blog to Paul Potts. You can link to him
here
if you like, but he's not actually the point of my story. Anyway, as Rachel and I were watching the video, she said, "Oh, I've seen him. Did you see the one with the little girl? She should come on right after. I think her name is Connie." Ok, two points to this story. A. How does my seven year old know about a YouTube video, make that two videos, that I never showed her?! This isn't going to be the last time this happens, but it sure made for a shock this first time. Turns out that when she was with my parents this summer, my Uncle Joe had showed both my mom and her the two videos. Whew. She hasn't taken to surfing on her own yet.
The other thing about this story is the actual video of Connie. You can watch it here.
As I watched this lovely little girl sing I was struck by the fact that she actually looked and sounded like the six year old that she is. Even when you see her sing in the finals, she still looks like a little girl. She's wearing a sweet little girl dress that was, or at least could have been, already in her closet. She has no make up on, or it's done to look like she has none on. And she just has clean, combed hair. In other words she does not look like a tart in a tiny body, which is totally what would have happened in an American TV talent show. And now that I think about it even more, there is no way that Paul Potts would have gotten the reaction that he got from an English audience from an American audience.
We are so dang shallow in this country! Why is that? Why do we seem to value style over substance and making everyone fit a very narrow definition of acceptability? I'm not trying to be anti-American, but this is something we should look at in ourselves and see what we can do about it. I can't change TV or magazines, but I can change how I respond to them and how I respond to people who don't fit the narrow definition of how you're "supposed" to look. I can also refuse to allow anyone, even myself, to put my children or me into set boxes.
here
The other thing about this story is the actual video of Connie. You can watch it here.
As I watched this lovely little girl sing I was struck by the fact that she actually looked and sounded like the six year old that she is. Even when you see her sing in the finals, she still looks like a little girl. She's wearing a sweet little girl dress that was, or at least could have been, already in her closet. She has no make up on, or it's done to look like she has none on. And she just has clean, combed hair. In other words she does not look like a tart in a tiny body, which is totally what would have happened in an American TV talent show. And now that I think about it even more, there is no way that Paul Potts would have gotten the reaction that he got from an English audience from an American audience.
We are so dang shallow in this country! Why is that? Why do we seem to value style over substance and making everyone fit a very narrow definition of acceptability? I'm not trying to be anti-American, but this is something we should look at in ourselves and see what we can do about it. I can't change TV or magazines, but I can change how I respond to them and how I respond to people who don't fit the narrow definition of how you're "supposed" to look. I can also refuse to allow anyone, even myself, to put my children or me into set boxes.
Thursday, October 18, 2007
Who's The Boss?
A Newsweek writer posed an interesting question this week. “Is it ever ok to discipline someone else’s child?” Her unofficial research said that the social norm is, “No, pretty much never.” There were a few exceptions: If a child is in danger, the child is a very close family friend or maybe a gentle (half-hearted?) discipline on a play date.
I have to admit, that pretty much lines up with how the social norm feels to me as well. If someone else gets on my kid’s case and I’m standing right there, I don’t take it as helpful, I take it as a backhanded reprimand to me for not disciplining my own child. On the other hand, if I’m not right there, it seems to me that another adult should step in. I might feel a little resentful, or embarrassed when I find out about it, but maybe it would do my child some good to know that he/she can’t get away with stuff when I’m not watching.
I don’t know. I suppose this could be a huge can of worms, because what if the parent disciplines my kid for doing something that is perfectly ok at my house? I know of a little girl whose friend and the friend’s parents told her that she shouldn’t be reading Harry Potter because it’s from the devil. JD would have totally gone off on that parent if it had happened to him.
On the other hand if I’m at a park or something and my child is not playing nice (Can you believe that I would have that concern with my sweeties?!) and I don’t notice, then I would hope somebody’s parent would tell my kid to knock it off.
In my neighborhood, I have other people’s kids at my house all the time. In the summer, I think some of them live here. In that case, it’s my house; they’re my rules. Of course, if the neighbor kids are doing something they shouldn’t be, and then my own kids are right in the thick of it, so it’s mostly a group scolding. I would hope that other neighbor’s would be the same way at their homes.
This is where being a teacher is helpful. I’m less inhibited about bossing around other kids.
I still don’t know though. Once when I was in line at the grocery store my girls were bickering about something. I decided that Abby was the instigator in the matter and “punished” her by making her sit in the cart. As I was putting her in, the old lady in front of us hissed, yes hissed, at Rachel, “You hit her, I saw you hit her.” It was pretty ugly and Rachel denied doing it. I felt bad, Rachel felt bad; it was a bad scene.
But if Rachel had hit her sister- she would totally deny it under pressure like that- then she shouldn’t get away with it. ARGH! What’s the right thing to do?
I have to admit, that pretty much lines up with how the social norm feels to me as well. If someone else gets on my kid’s case and I’m standing right there, I don’t take it as helpful, I take it as a backhanded reprimand to me for not disciplining my own child. On the other hand, if I’m not right there, it seems to me that another adult should step in. I might feel a little resentful, or embarrassed when I find out about it, but maybe it would do my child some good to know that he/she can’t get away with stuff when I’m not watching.
I don’t know. I suppose this could be a huge can of worms, because what if the parent disciplines my kid for doing something that is perfectly ok at my house? I know of a little girl whose friend and the friend’s parents told her that she shouldn’t be reading Harry Potter because it’s from the devil. JD would have totally gone off on that parent if it had happened to him.
On the other hand if I’m at a park or something and my child is not playing nice (Can you believe that I would have that concern with my sweeties?!) and I don’t notice, then I would hope somebody’s parent would tell my kid to knock it off.
In my neighborhood, I have other people’s kids at my house all the time. In the summer, I think some of them live here. In that case, it’s my house; they’re my rules. Of course, if the neighbor kids are doing something they shouldn’t be, and then my own kids are right in the thick of it, so it’s mostly a group scolding. I would hope that other neighbor’s would be the same way at their homes.
This is where being a teacher is helpful. I’m less inhibited about bossing around other kids.
I still don’t know though. Once when I was in line at the grocery store my girls were bickering about something. I decided that Abby was the instigator in the matter and “punished” her by making her sit in the cart. As I was putting her in, the old lady in front of us hissed, yes hissed, at Rachel, “You hit her, I saw you hit her.” It was pretty ugly and Rachel denied doing it. I felt bad, Rachel felt bad; it was a bad scene.
But if Rachel had hit her sister- she would totally deny it under pressure like that- then she shouldn’t get away with it. ARGH! What’s the right thing to do?
Saturday, October 13, 2007
The Freegans
You might not have heard of them. I just learned about Freegans a few weeks ago in Newsweek. They're people who try to live without spending any money. They're name comes from that fact and the fact that they are also vegans. They even try to get their food free by foraging. Since they live in urban areas, that means foraging in dumpsters. Yes, dumpsters. Apparently that's not as nasty as it sounds if you know where to look. Restaurants and grocery stores through out an amazing amount of perfectly good food.
Here's the part that's stuck in my head about their plan. I hesitated for days to post my thought because in so many ways they have the right idea and I wonder if I am doing any better. However, it seems to me that there's a break down in their logic. They want to disengage themselves from the capitalist machine, but at the same time they are survival depends on Someone being apart of that same machine. Part of living free can mean living on a friend's couch, in addition to the foraging. Capitalists create the “habitat” in which they live and forage.
It seems to me that their hearts are totally in the right place. There is a lot of waste in our capitalist economy and that same economy shuts out groups of people and forces them to live in unchosen poverty. But. It seems to me that Second Harvest, a charity that takes that same waste and shares it with people in need, has a better plan. (Not that Second Harvest digs in dumpsters. They arrange to take the excess before it gets to the dumpter.)
From what I read, most of the Freegans are well-educated people who have or had good, well paying jobs. If they want to disengage maybe they should try what all the hippie farm collectives tried and at least do the work of creating the food and shelter themselves.
Here's the part that's stuck in my head about their plan. I hesitated for days to post my thought because in so many ways they have the right idea and I wonder if I am doing any better. However, it seems to me that there's a break down in their logic. They want to disengage themselves from the capitalist machine, but at the same time they are survival depends on Someone being apart of that same machine. Part of living free can mean living on a friend's couch, in addition to the foraging. Capitalists create the “habitat” in which they live and forage.
It seems to me that their hearts are totally in the right place. There is a lot of waste in our capitalist economy and that same economy shuts out groups of people and forces them to live in unchosen poverty. But. It seems to me that Second Harvest, a charity that takes that same waste and shares it with people in need, has a better plan. (Not that Second Harvest digs in dumpsters. They arrange to take the excess before it gets to the dumpter.)
From what I read, most of the Freegans are well-educated people who have or had good, well paying jobs. If they want to disengage maybe they should try what all the hippie farm collectives tried and at least do the work of creating the food and shelter themselves.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)